Fictional scenario
Entirely fictional case. Marcos, an adult observed after an everyday activity, says, “I am breathing differently and need to stop.” The exercise provides incomplete observations to practise selecting additional information. It does not reproduce a real care situation.
Initial information
- Shallow breathing is observed during the conversation. Comparison with his baseline status is missing.
- No information about cough or secretions is provided.
- There is an isolated device reading, without measurement conditions or a reliable contextual value. It is not used to confirm a hypothesis.
- No swallowing or intake difficulties or other information supporting 00039 are described.
Information still needed
- Onset, duration, preceding activity, pain, perception, progression and a complete respiratory assessment.
- Cough effectiveness and the presence or absence of relevant secretions.
- Measurement quality and other clinical information allowing gas exchange to be interpreted.
Questions for reasoning
- What focus does 00032 explore, and which initial observation makes it a reasonable hypothesis?
- What information would distinguish 00031 from 00032?
- Why does an isolated reading not allow 00030 to be confirmed?
- What would you do if sufficient information is missing or deterioration occurs during assessment?
Case update
As the case is expanded, Marcos reports that discomfort limits the depth of his breathing. Professional assessment provides no evidence of difficulty mobilising secretions. The initial measurement proves unusable; the case still does not provide enough evidence to draw a conclusion about gas exchange.
Show the reasoned solution
00032 is the best-supported hypothesis for further study because of the observed pattern and the account, but indicators and factors still need to be checked. Discomfort is not turned into a confirmed cause.
00031 loses support when the described assessment finds no evidence of difficulty clearing the airway. It is not declared impossible at any later time.
00030 remains unconfirmed because interpretable information is lacking. “Insufficient information” is a valid answer here, not an error that must be filled with a label.
00039 is not included: the case provides no specific basis for it. Diagnoses should not be added because they belong to the same respiratory area.
The working formulation links hypothesis 00032 to the observed shallow pattern and identifies what is missing. An educational goal would be to describe comparable changes in pattern and comfort with an individual review timeframe. The team determines specific measures after assessment; this case does not prescribe oxygen or techniques.
If deterioration occurred, timely clinical care would take priority without waiting to complete the classification. The next review may retain, change or reject the hypotheses.
Related diagnosis pages
- 00032 · Ineffective breathing pattern NEW
- 00031 · Ineffective airway clearance NEW
- 00030 · Impaired gas exchange NEW
Use the educational template · Version 1.0
Sources
Original fictional educational scenario. The codes refer to the sources listed on each diagnosis page. INKA/NANDA framework for assessment and diagnostic reasoning.