Fictional scenario
Entirely fictional case. Elena, an adult recovering after planned surgery, wants to sit in the armchair to talk with her daughter. She says, “It hurts when I sit up; I would rather do it with help.” Before surgery, she transferred independently. The case does not prescribe when to mobilise or replace the team’s instructions.
Initial information
- She reports pain when sitting up and asks for support. A complete pain assessment is not yet provided.
- She needs help with a transfer she previously performed independently.
- There is a recent incision. The case provides no evidence of infection and does not allow it to be definitively excluded.
- Her expressed priority is to be comfortable and take part in the conversation, not reach a predetermined number.
Information still needed
- Procedure instructions and restrictions, progression and pain assessment.
- Current ability, precise support needed, tolerance and safe conditions for the activity.
- The condition of the incision and other relevant information for assessing risk and possible current problems.
- The observed transfer difficulty requires assessment of mobility safety and possible fall risk: balance, strength, dizziness, medication, surroundings and history. 00303 cannot yet be automatically confirmed, nor can the absence of risk be concluded.
Questions for reasoning
- Which information supports exploring 00132, and which describes a distinct functional limitation?
- How would you formulate risk 00004 without inventing manifestations of infection?
- What would you ask before including 00303?
- What goal would you agree on with Elena, and what finding would change the priority?
Case update
After the assessment is completed and the support agreed by the team is provided, Elena participates in the transfer, reports greater comfort and talks while seated. She still needs help. No new evidence of infection or unsteadiness is provided; none should be invented.
Show the reasoned solution
00132 and 00085 are relevant hypotheses to check: the account provides an experience of pain and the observation a functional limitation. It has not been established that pain alone explains the entire limitation.
00004 is explored as a contextual risk. Its formulation does not require symptoms of an existing infection. If the focus is specifically the incision, compare it with 00500 before choosing the label; the choice requires information and checking against the authorised classification. If new findings suggesting infection emerged, that problem would need assessment rather than being hidden under a risk label.
The need for help during the transfer is relevant individual information for assessing fall risk. It does not require 00303 to be confirmed, but neither does it allow it to be ruled out because previous falls or unsteadiness are not described. The assessment is completed and safe support agreed before the activity.
The priority is agreed with attention to safety, assessment and Elena’s goal. The update shows participation and comfort, but does not prove complete recovery. Required support, tolerance and preferences are reviewed at the next assessment.
Provisional educational formulation: hypothesis 00132 supported by reported pain when sitting up; hypothesis 00085 supported by the need for help with a previously independent transfer. Related factors and exact wording must be checked before using a clinical formulation.
Related diagnosis pages
- 00132 · Acute pain NEW
- 00085 · Impaired physical mobility NEW
- 00004 · Risk for infection NEW
- 00303 · Risk for adult falls NEW
Use the educational template · Version 1.0
Sources
Original fictional educational scenario. The codes refer to the sources listed on each diagnosis page. INKA/NANDA framework for assessment and diagnostic reasoning.